Pages

Friday, May 21, 2010

Khaps of haryana hinterland: Untouchables of Digital Age

  Navin Jindal is in news now-a-days for all the wrong reasons. Suddenly the tech savvy business czar is out of favour, both from political as well as media circles. And the reason is that he came in support of the demand of haryana's powerful social councils (The Khaps) of banning same gotra marriage.
             After the killings of many couples by their family members and the members of society ,  the khaps were facing the ire of new age media and perceived as medieval  and barbaric by urban middle and higher class ,  though in many cases the violence was the instant reaction of angry family, we cant deny the fact that local villagers and the Khaps were approvers if not facilitators of these acts. In such circumstances support of navin jindal was surprising to many guys and media went haywire to condemn him ,but this started a very constructive debate which is very good for Indian democracy.
          There is a general tendency that  a well educated and socially upward person should support love marriages and if you are on the other side, you are regressive, backward , foolish etc..etc. In the same light everyone in Delhi is supporting love marriages happening in haryana and delhites and other denizens of urban areas are not much concerned about gotra as in cosmopolitan circles these are meaningless things now a days.People who are concerned only about their 3-4 member family (and some times not even for them) cant comprehend how all members of a gotra can be brothers and sisters.
          But it will be prudent to state here that village life is entirely different from urban culture and rural society is still very well knit and most of time they live like extended families and marriages in the same village disturb this structure , breaks the walls of trust so people out there are opposed to it , in general.
Not only in haryana, even in rajasthan , Gujarat and in some parts of MP same gotra marriages are socially prohibited and societies normally cut off or limit their interactions with people involved in such marriages. But Haryana's case was more accentuated because of the large scale killings and violence involved.
             It appears that now Khaps has learned that violence is not the solution to this problem. In a democracy they can raise their demands and try to change the Hindu marriage act and inculcate the ban on same gotra marriage in the act. Initially all political parties, newspapers,  TV channels etc..etc were opposed to this but once Navin Jindal came in open to support Khaps now some people are seeing some logic in this. And even if you are opposed to it there is no harm in listening to some one's demands. After all we are in a democracy and we value age old social and religious practices. We have separate personal laws for different religions, Sikhs are allowed to keep turban in armed forces where others are not, Muslims are allowed to keep 4 wives others are not.  So in nutshell, we value social traditions so whether we accept their demands or not, we should at least hear them try to reason out with them, this is the only way to bring someone in mainstream, if they have logic we should not hide away from accepting their demands.
            Few days back even baba ramdev said that he is also in favour of the demands of khaps as long as they are raising their voices peacefully and democratically.
My view is that, I am in favour of democracy. I am in favour of the right of every citizen to raise his voice peacefully for the issues he believes he should raise his voice. Whether his demands will be accepted or not , does not bother me. Whether he belongs to a Khap or to Gymkhana Club , Doesn't bother me.

No comments:

Post a Comment